Let’s Discuss: The Bad Boy

When I was younger, I loved the bad boy trope. I loved it in books, I loved it in movies, and I fantasized about it in real life. Eventually, I dated the guy who got into trouble, the guy who was “bad”, and the guy who was a player. It was all part of this belief that if he loved me, he would change for me.

Even though I know better, I still find myself reading books about that guy. The girl is usually “good” and tries to ignore the boy’s advances. Usually, he gives up his bachelor lifestyle for her because he loves her and eventually, they get their happily ever after. And maybe there isn’t anything wrong with this story. After all, do we really find this guy attractive in real life?

I guess I once did, back in college. But after four years, I finally figured it out. And now as an adult, I have a hard time buying into those romances. What’s wrong with the guy who’s kind and isn’t a womanizer? Is he really all that boring?

In all honesty, I’m conflicted on the topic. On the one hand, fiction is a way to escape and live in a fantasy world.  It isn’t always meant to be realistic.And while the “bad boy” might promote this idea that someone can change another person, it also teaches us that there’s something good in everyone.  But on the other hand, the stories and characters we are exposed to, especially when we are younger, can definitely shape who we are and how we live ours lives. For me, I definitely bought into the idea that I could change the “bad boy”. And is this really a healthy way for people to approach relationships?

But I also hate the idea of censorship. I hate the idea of saying that ideas and themes are dangerous. It’s a slippery slope that leads to a world I’d rather not live in. Ultimately, I don’t want to say that the bad boy doesn’t have a place in literature because he does. But I also appreciate a work that doesn’t portray him as a project to be fixed by the leading lady.

One of the things I love about the book community is that there’s always discussion around these topics. Just because a book has a happily ever after doesn’t mean you can’t talk about the pitfalls of the characters and their relationships. It doesn’t mean you can’t talk about why the romance was unhealthy and borderline abusive. And maybe that’s enough.

What are your thoughts? Let me know in the comments below!


7 thoughts on “Let’s Discuss: The Bad Boy

  1. notsomoderngirl says:

    Great idea for a post! I haven’t had any real life experiences with bad boys, but I love them in books, and definitely there’s something attractive about them in real life. I completely agree that they are often unrealistic in real life (although I have no experience of my own haha) but then again, like you say, censorship is such an issue, especially in YA. Great post, look forward to reading more discussions like it 🙂


  2. the bookaholic dreamer says:

    This is a great discussion point!! I was in love with the bad boy trope when I was younger too but nowadays I find it really problematic. I feel like books and movies that romanticize relationships in which the guy is mean/cheats and the girl stays with him because she thinks he will change can bleed into real life and motivate individuals to allow others to treat them badly. These days I actually enjoy reading about kind romantic interests that are precious cinnamon rolls but I do understand the pull towards the bad boy trope. I don’t think censorship is ever the option and I don’t think that the bad boy trope is causing much seriously dangerous consequences. But I sometimes wish that we had more kind romantic interests in books. I really liked your discussion post and I’m eagerly waiting to read your next one 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

    • Megan says:

      Thanks for reading and responding! Exactly. I wouldn’t say it’s dangerous either, because obviously I get the bad boy appeal, but yeah. It would be nice to see more romantic interests that were kind. I’m glad I’m not the only one!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Kaleena @ Reader Voracious says:

    This is such an important topic, and one I have thought a lot about. When I was younger, I LOVED Spike from Buffy, the Bad Guy enemies-to-lovers with a redemption arc that to this day still sets my soul ablaze.

    But I then found myself in a relationship that was borderline toxic, yet I stuck around because deep down I thought he would change. And like ten years later I think I was expecting a redemption arc. That he would choose to be a better man for me. And that’s harmful; there’s a difference between fiction and reality, but when you subconsciously make choices based on those biases & expectations that go against how you want to be treated, it’s a problem.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s